Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

For comparison of laser scanning products

Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

Postby cadcoke5 » Thu Feb 16, 2017 10:01 pm

I have kept an eye on the 3D scanning industry for over two decades, hoping the cost would eventually come down enough to use it in my industry. We would need to scan warehouse facilities and the office spaces in them. Typical sizes are a max of 150ft Square. Accuracy +/- 1" is sufficient.

I came across the Zeb Rivo and Zeb 1 scanners by GeoSLAM. My notes must be messed up, because I have the base scanners, Zeb1 at $2,500 and the Zeb Revo at $$2,360 . But, the Revo is the more expensive machine, so perhaps I just reversed the prices.

Both of these scanners require proprietary software to create the point cloud. You can purchase the unit with the software. The Revo is $4,500 for the Revo, and the Zeb1 is $3,500. Or alternatively, to save up-front money, you can choose to use their cloud service for the processing, at some price per scan (though the dealer has not gotten back to me with an estimated price on that).

But, their system only gives you the point cloud. You also need specialized software to do anything useful with the point cloud. PointCab was recommended to me. It costs $3,500 USD.

In regards to cloud software tied to a piece of hardware, this is obviously a major gamble. If the vendor goes under, or some other problem prevents you from accessing the cloud, you are stuck with a very expensive door-stop. So, cloud processing is off the table, from my perspective.

So, the entry point for scanning hardware and the necessary software seems to be $7,000.

2nd issue, is the actual cost/benefit ratio.

I work in an industry that needs to install large equipment into existing warehouse facilities, and we often need to do an as-built of the space. Occasionally, the space is somewhat convoluted or has large equipment in the way, making manual efforts more difficult. I am evaluating if the idea of a laser scan or other comparable technology is comparable in price to sending out a guy with a tape measure. That guy is normally an engineer, since of course, he has to go to the site and get familiar with it anyway. On a few occasions we have had to send him back out for a missed measurement. And sometimes there were details that would be nice to have had, but we get by without it.

In some ways, a facility scan gives you too much information. 2D drawings are a simplification of the real-world object. Walls are nearly always drawn straight, and corners are perpendicular. It takes time to convert a scan into a 2D drawing that follows the norm.

I had hoped that Google's project Tango would make an even lower price entry-point, and it would so cheap and easy enough to use, that we might just mail the equipment to the customer, and have them do the scan.

Automatic photo-registration of the scan, coupled with a set of VR goggles might have permitted the engineer to take a virtual tour of the facility. Though, for large projects, the human element of a real face-to-face meeting with the engineer is required at some point. But, for overseas projects, I would hope to be able to keep the engineer down to just a single trip.

But, I have been told that Tango is just not accurate enough at the warehouse scale. Moreover, the software to do what I want, is still in the world of the university research project, rather than a real-world product.

The Zeb Rivo seems to be fairly easy to use, but not something I would send to a customer. Nor does it currently have the photo registration and VR integration to use it as I would hope.

My current thinking is that the $7,000 for hardware/software, plus the CAD time to do the work is probably not worth it for us. The software/hardware cost would probably need to be under $3,000 to even consider it.

Any other thoughts on this?
cadcoke5
I have made <0 posts
I have made <0 posts
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Thu Feb 16, 2017 4:35 pm
Full Name: Joe Dunfee
Company Details: Tropical
Company Position Title: Engineer
Country: USA
Linkedin Profile: No

Re: Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

Postby sersab » Fri Feb 17, 2017 11:06 am

cadcoke5 wrote:I came across the Zeb Rivo and Zeb 1 scanners by GeoSLAM. My notes must be messed up, because I have the base scanners, Zeb1 at $2,500 and the Zeb Revo at $$2,360 . But, the Revo is the more expensive machine, so perhaps I just reversed the prices.


Joe, are you sure about these prices? They don't sound right to me.
I think they are much more expensive then this.
Sergio

3DScan - 3D Laser Scanning and topography
T +39 039 6980186 | Mail info@3dscan.it | Web http://www.3dscan.it/en/
User avatar
sersab
I have made 50-60 posts
I have made 50-60 posts
 
Posts: 54
Joined: Wed May 01, 2013 11:37 am
Full Name: Sergio Sabbatini
Company Details: 3DScan.it
Company Position Title: CEO
Country: Italia
Skype Name: sersab
Linkedin Profile: Yes

Re: Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

Postby landmeterbeuckx » Fri Feb 17, 2017 1:03 pm

I think he gives the prices of a real disto instead of a zeb. :D
LSBbvba
Image
Surveying services - 3D Laserscanning
Tel : +3211661621
www.landmeter-beuckx.be
info@landmeter-beuckx.be
landmeterbeuckx
I have made 90-100 posts
I have made 90-100 posts
 
Posts: 94
Joined: Tue May 01, 2012 5:19 pm
Full Name: Lieven Beuckx
Company Details: Studiebureau Beuckx
Company Position Title: Owner
Country: Belgium
Linkedin Profile: Yes

Re: Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

Postby KDersch » Fri Feb 17, 2017 2:08 pm

The work practices of your company sound pretty similar to some of our projects. FARO has recently released some shorter ranger scanners that I think around around $20,000. SCENE is another $6,000 I believe. This would get you the very basics needed besides spheres and computer hardware.

We generally work in NavisWorks and compare our proposed work directly to the pointcloud to verify layout conditions and constraints. We utilize PointSense when necessary to draw 2D plans and section cuts from the data in a pretty efficient manner. The issue we run into, as you mentioned, is that 2D drawings are a simplification of the real world where walls are not plumb or perpendicular and floors are not flat. We always need to draw a line in the sand as to what we can accept or not accept for inaccuracy on a project.
KDersch
I have made 40-50 posts
I have made 40-50 posts
 
Posts: 44
Joined: Wed Jun 01, 2016 11:54 am
Full Name: Kyle Dersch
Company Details: Matix Technologies
Company Position Title: Engineer
Country: USA
Skype Name: kddersch@matrixti.com
Linkedin Profile: Yes

Re: Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

Postby Brett » Fri Feb 17, 2017 5:22 pm

Hi Joe,

The Zeb is more expensive than the proces you have in your notes. I'm sure one of the US distributors will be in touch with you once they have seen your post.

For your required accuracy I can recommend the Revo & Pointcab combination. The main factor you will save money on will be the site time. You will be on site for hours rather than days when measuring big buildings.

With the Zebcam too you won't need to revisit site for those missed dims.
Sent from my Sinclair ZX Spectrum+ using tapatalk
User avatar
Brett
I have made 60-70 posts
I have made 60-70 posts
 
Posts: 65
Joined: Tue Oct 04, 2011 2:57 pm
Full Name: Brett Duffield
Company Details: Omega Geomatics
Company Position Title: Director
Country: England

Re: Cost entry-point for scanning vs. tape measure

Postby tbwester » Fri Feb 17, 2017 7:15 pm

Joe check out matterport scanners. that is your cheapest option, but it will still run you 5-6k all-in. They are good to within 1%, x/y - not exactly sure of your use-case, but it may be good enough.

Zeb units go new for ~40k, used you could probably find cheaper, but still will be well above 7k.
tbwester
V.I.P Member
V.I.P Member
 
Posts: 688
Joined: Fri Apr 20, 2012 1:49 pm
Location: SC/NYC
Full Name: Thad Wester
Company Details: WeWork
Company Position Title: Head of Reality Capture
Country: USA
Linkedin Profile: Yes


Return to Product Comparison

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

 
SiteLock

Stay in touch    RSS feed    Twitter    Youtube    Linkedin

LSF SPONSOR

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy
DouZa Webdesign